DEVELOPMENTS. Review Essay – Ernst Forsthoff and the Intellectual. History of German Administrative Law. By Florian Meinel*. [Christian Schütte, Progressive. Briefwechsel Ernst Forsthoff – Carl Schmitt (German Edition) Jun 04, by Angela Reinthal, Reinhard Mußgnug, Dorothee Mußgnug. Request PDF on ResearchGate | On Jan 1, , Florian Meinel and others published Review Essay – Ernst Forsthoff and the Intellectual History of German.

Author: Talabar Vujas
Country: Armenia
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Marketing
Published (Last): 19 April 2015
Pages: 328
PDF File Size: 18.10 Mb
ePub File Size: 8.76 Mb
ISBN: 342-8-73219-556-6
Downloads: 95531
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Nemuro

Oh no, there’s been an error

As Forsthoff argued, “Luther completely ripped apart the connection between earthly kingdom and divine commandment. It was time now for a new state, based on real political authority, unifying all of the German world. Shopbop Designer Fashion Brands.

JCM,I: Science Logic and Mathematics. Second, the problem of the state, for Schmitt the ultimate truth of politics, underlay this contradiction. Springer,III: In short, Carl Schmitt’s “qualitative social state” had assumed real form. His desire to make Schmitt’s state a reality led to a suspension of his critical and complex legal judgment, I will argue.

But he would never return to the enthusiasm–and to the abdication of scholarly responsibility–of his years at the University of Frankfurt. It is rather to indicate what Forsthoff saw in him.

Amazon Drive Forsthofg storage from Amazon. He advocated instead National Socialist measures to pull church and state together. Request removal from index. Ernst Cassirer in 20th Century Philosophy categorize this paper. Gerhart Niemeyer, 6th ed.

The spiritual and social world of Bismarck’s day had collapsed, he wrnst, and there was no going back. To reach this new state, however, the Reich would have to be reorganized from top to bottom, perhaps around a new Prussia whose government was unified with that of the Reich as a whole.

Ernst Forsthoff – Wikipedia

It acclaimed the end of democracy, welcomed authoritarian rule, and embraced anti-Semitism which had not appeared in Forsthoff’s published work before. Muller, The Other God that Failed: Get fast, free shipping with Amazon Prime.


These themes shaped Forsthoff’s thinking before Withoutabox Submit to Film Festivals. Carl Schmitt, whose star was rapidly rising under National Socialism, had intervened to support Forsthoff.

Nationalist and Nazi students had disrupted lectures in law by democrats and Jews, such as Hans Nawiasky and Hans Kelsen. Foesthoff than a model university, Frankfurt became a holding-place for less usable professors.

For Forsthoff, it was ednst great step forward to eliminate municipal elections; for the local Gauleiter to appoint in their place municipal councils; and to require SA and SS representation on the councils.

Already inaccording to Reinhard Mehring, Schmitt referred to Ernst Forsthoff as a “hideous man” scheusslicher Kerl. Amazon Advertising Find, attract, and engage customers. But the different emphases matter a great deal. He agreed, of course, with their condemnations of Dibelius, whose discussion ernt just war raised the possibility of an unjust German war.

David Dyzenhaus, Legality and Legitimacy: Not only did he support the dictatorship; not only did he endorse the anti-Semitic measures of the first years hardly a surprise given his upbringing in a nationalist, conservative, Protestant family. Klein, Forsthoff stated that he had initially pinned “high hopes on National Socialism” and had a positive relationship to the movement, but by had “seen his error and from a supporter became a determined opponent.

Forsthoff argued–like Schmitt–from prior conceptual definition to the law itself; his assertions lacked clear positive law to support them. Forsthoff’s Pseudonymous Writings The points of criticism in Forsthoff’s pseudonymous publications were virtually identical to those in the essays he published under his own name.

Meinel has carefully noted the points where Forsthoff distinguished his interpretation from Schmitt. Help us improve our Author Pages by updating your bibliography and submitting a new or current image and biography.

Ernst Forsthoff 13 SeptemberLaar — 13 AugustHeidelberg was a German scholar of constitutional law and a leading theorist of administrative law. The removal of professors, especially those of Jewish descent, paralyzed Frankfurt University–and was accepted passively by most of those scholars who remained.


This entry has no external links. But with the collapse of that stable order, with the Protestant break between law and God, law descended into “the mere formal act of a legislator”: Nomos,25; Forsthoff, “Recht, Richter und nationalsozialistische Revolution,” Deutsches Adelsblatt The difference lay in how explicit his conclusions were.

Forsthoff’s Frankfurt years followed him for the rest of his life, sowing doubt and distrust among others, including other conservatives. This article needs additional citations for verification.

The Importance of Forwthoff Ernst: And yet, Forsthoff continued to cite Schmitt prominently. Five points dominated his arguments: He was willing to subject his Protestant church to the whims of the National Socialist state; he was willing to see communal self-government subordinate to local party leaders; he was willing to throw overboard long-standing legal traditions of the German lands, most important the principle of judicial independence, and indeed to call for facts to overwhelm words in legal practice.

He stated that neither culture, economy, family, nor market could be completely subjected to administrative control. History of Western Philosophy.

Similar authors to follow

This article has no associated abstract. High to Low Avg. His work on Art. He offered a historical narrative forsrhoff political analysis of the inevitable instability of liberal democracy, and the threat it posed to order, a history that ednst the grand reactionary narratives of Joseph de Maistre and others of the nineteenth century, updating them for the cynical mood of post-war Germany.

But Schmitt was more than that for Forsthoff and for other young, anti- republican intellectuals in the Republic.